Diners, Restaurants, and Eateries in Shelter Island New York
Check out all the food options to eat in Shelter Island New York. A quality dining experience is important, not to mention a well balanced and delicious meal so get the most out of your food in one of the 5 restaurant options. Shelter Island New York has a ton of places to eat, so choose wisely, not hungerly!
Tuck Shop75 Menantic Road
Shelter Island New York, 11964
in county Suffolk
Phone: (631) 749-1548
Primo Pizza & Restaurant53 Ferry Road
Shelter Island New York, 11964
in county Suffolk
Phone: (631) 749-2732
Barefoot Charlies85 North Ferry Road
Shelter Island New York, 11964
in county Suffolk
Phone: (631) 749-1900
Cafe 2727 North Ferry Rd
Shelter Island New York, 11964
in county Suffolk
Phone: (631) 749-2727
Michael Anthonys At Dering Harbor Inn65 South Menantic Rd
Shelter Island New York, 11964
in county Suffolk
Phone: (631) 749-3460